Calahora, a remarkable Sephardic family in Poland




My upcoming paper (now over 30 pages and counting) explores the history and genealogy of Sephardic Jews who settled in Eastern Europe. It is a subject that I find fascinating and I believe is woefully unexplored.
In the course of my research I stumbled across a remarkable family -about whom I will cite here only several tidbits- namely the Kalahora/Calahora family of Poland.
Of the Patriarch Solomon’s six children, Moses continued the family branch in Cracow, and Israel Samuel (1560-1640), the Rabbi of Lenchista founded the Poznan branch. One of Israel Samuel’s sons was Matityahu Calahora(pictured, third from top), who according to the contemporary Polish historian, Kochowski was a “well-known physician with an extensive practice in Christian and even clerical circles”. Matityahu’s life came to a violent end when he became embroiled in a religious dispute with a Dominican friar named Havlin. The Russian- Jewish historian Simon Dubnow describes the event, disturbing in its sheer brutality:
The priest invited Calahora to a disputation in the cloister, but the Jew declined, promising to expound his views in writing. A few days later the priest found on his chair in the church a statement written in German and containing a violent arraignment of the cult of the Immaculate Virgin. It is not impossible that the statement was composed and placed in the church by an adherent of the "Reformation or the Arian heresy" both of which were then the object of persecution in Poland. However, the Dominican decided that Calahora was the author, and brought the charge of blasphemy against him. The Court of the Royal Castle cross-examined the defendant under torture, without being able to obtain a confession. Wit- nesses testified that Calahora was not even able to write German. Being a native of Italy, he used the Italian language in his conversations with the Dominican. In spite of all this evidence, the unfortunate Calahora was sentenced to be burned at the stake. The alarmed Jewish community raised a protest, and the case was accordingly transferred to the highest court in Piotrkov. The accused was sent in chains to Piotrkov, together with the plaintiff and the witnesses. But the arch-Catholic tribunal confirmed the verdict of the lower court, ordering that the sentence be executed in the following barbarous sequence: first the lips of the " blasphemer " to be cut off ; next his hand that had held the fateful statement to be burned; then the tongue, which had spoken against the Christian religion, to be excised ; finally the body to be burned at the stake, and the ashes of the victim to be loaded into a cannon and discharged into the air. This cannibal ceremonial was faithfully carried out on December 13, 1663, on the market place of Piotrkov. For two centuries the Jews of Cracow followed the custom of reciting, on the fourteenth of Kislev, in the old synagogue of that city, a memorial prayer for the soul of the martyr Calahora. [2]
Matityahu’s son Michael and his two grandsons were also notable physicians in Poland. Matityahu's brother, Solomon Calahora married the daughter of the Posen physician, Judah de Lima (another Sephardic family that settled in Poland, of whom we shall talk more later).
One of Solomon's sons was Joseph (1601-1696), also known as Joseph Darshan (literally, preacher) of Poznan who authored a popular work on ethical and moral obligations, Yesod Yosef , published in Frankfurt, in 1679 (pictured first from top). Joseph's son, Arye Leib Kalifari, a preacher in Posen was the founder of the Landsberg and Posner families. Arye Leib became the second member of this family to be martyred when he was arrested and tortured by the Catholic authorities in 1735 in the course of a blood libel. Heinrich Graetz describes the event in his History of the Jews:
Adalbert Yablonowitz, a son of a prominent citzizen disappeared from his home and his mutilated body was found in a village near Posen. The Christian population of Posen....at once charged the Jews with the crime. The majority of the Jews of Posen-fearing violence- fled for their lives. The preacher, Aryeh Leib; the communal representative Jacob ben Pinhas and 2 parnasim Isaac and Hertz were seized and thrown in prison. The preacher and the representative were tortured and died in prison (Arye Leib rebuffed an offer to spare his life if he converted--J.D.) . The trial of the parnasim and 5 other prominent Jews dragged on for nearly 4 years when a foreign community, Vienna, it seems, procured an able advocate who succeeded in proving the innocence of the acccused and the latter were released in 1740. [3]
Aryeh Leib's great-grandson, Solomon Posner (1780-1863) was the author of a family chronicle, Toar Penei Shlomo.
Stanislaw Posner(pictured, fourth from top), pseudonym: Henryk Bezmaski(1868-1930) was a grandson of the aforementioned Solomon Posner and a Polish socialist activist, senator, lawyer and publicist. He also authored Poland as an Independent Economic Unit. See more about him here.
Notes:
[1]. Calahora was only one of a number of Jewish physicians who settled in Poland at that time. Other notable personages include: Samuel de Lima, Samuel bar Meshulam, Shlomo Ashkenazy, the brothers Levi-Lieberman Fortis Ostila, and Moses Montalto.
Labels: ashkenazim, calahora, calvary, jews poland, kalahora, kalifari, landsberg, posner, sephardim, sephardim eastern europe, stanislaw posner

5 Comments:
The story of the Sephardic physician Dr Kalahora and his sons is fascinating! Hahistorion, you put a human face on the DNA research I do. I am going to look for DNA evidence in Family Tree DNA and ysearch for all the surnames of the Kalahora descandants as well as the other Sephardic physicians you mention who migrated to Poland. If modern Ashkenazi families with recent Polish ancestry who carry these surnames can link their ancestors to Solomon Kalahora or the other Sephardic physicians (through documentation), then I will have a treasure trove of Sephardic DNA. Any Ashkenazi Jewish male whose Y-DNA matches these families would also have Sephardic ancestry, whether they are aware of it or not.
Judy Simon
administrator, Iberian Ashkenaz Y-DNA project
this is incredible work! i suspected much of this but lacked the resources to look into it. keep up the amazing work--i look forward to reading your article!
Hi Joel,
I have been following your blog for quite a while now, and am really enjoying your pieces.
Let me, however, express some criticism regarding your genealogy of the Kalahora family; a critique that holds true for a lot of Jewish genealogy. You seem to base your genealogy on secondary sources; some books are quite dated, and hence, I doubt that they would be considered scientific in an academic context, because the claims in such publications are difficult to test or verify. You seem to construct a family tree by extracting bits and bits from a variety of books; a sentence here, a passage there, from books that carry fairly generic titles such as '"History of the Jews in Russia and Poland ". How would a writer of a comprehensive book on Jewish history in Poland and Russia have the time to check a specific fact on the Kalahora family? Presumably, that writer based himself on yet another book, and not on a primary source either. Don't get me wrong, I have used this "scrap-methodology" myself far too often; however, I also realize its limits; it's a not a scientific method. I have used such a method because 1) lack of primary sources 2) it would be extremely difficult to go through primary sources. One would have to actually visit archives in Poland, Spain, Russia etc and master all the languages and dialects related to the topic). It would take countless years and a tremendous amount of energy to complete a single genealogy, however, the result would be something scientific, and would not have such a impressionistic, rudimentary quality as your (and my own) work. I agree that our "naive" approach is probably the best possible, realistic alternative to real scientific research, and I would also very much encourage you to continue your research; however, - i mean this more as a general observation- it's a pity that most Jewish genealogy publications aren't capable of going beyond the anecdotal, beyond secondary sources. We need to work towards a fact-based, veriable scientific quality standard for Jewish genealogies, that transcends anecdote and wild speculations that are solely based on similarities of surnames.
Avrum, your criticisms are welcome and valid. This blog affords me the opportunity to publish snippets regarding subjects that I am interested in. I am planning on discussing these subjects more in depth in the future (perhaps in book format) which I assure you will be well researched and annotated. Thanks for your comment.
1) Elias Joseph Juda de Lima Pozner Norden - born 1694 in Posen died 1758 in Amsterdam, and
2) Abraham Joseph Juda Pozner - born 1697 in Posen and died 1728 in Amsterdam.
Do you know the possible relationship, if any, to your Juda de Lima?
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home